Why 'opera' rather than 'oratorio'?

In today's music history books you usually find Anima e Corpo described as the first oratorio: while the first opera is described as the production of Orfeo and Euridice, with part of the music composed by Giulio Caccini, part by Jacopo Peri, each of whom published a complete version shortly afterwards.

So what's an oratorio? Firstly it's the Italian word for a place where people pray, adopted in English as 'oratory', as in London's Brompton Oratory; secondly it's a piece performed in such a place, and so normally having a religious text: Anima e Corpo was indeed first performed in an oratorio, and according to the publisher Guidotti in 1600 it was the first time the genre 'rappresentatione' in musica affetuosa had been used in a devotional context.

However the association people have today with words is that, while an opera is an extended dramatic work with costume, scenery, make-up, acting, gestures and movement, often even a ballet, an oratorio has none of those things - the performers wear concert clothes, there is no scenery, make-up, acting, nor gestures: and the only movement is when people stand up or sit down.

The foreword to the printed edition of 1600 discusses the use of all the aspects characteristic of an opera, so to describe it as an oratorio today gives completely the wrong impression of what it was then.

Of course, neither term, 'opera' or 'oratorio' were used until long after 1600: Anima e Corpo is described as a 'rappresentatione', the earlier examples of the genre as 'pastorale': but these two terms describe different aspects - 'rappresentatione' says it's a dramatic performance, 'pastorale' that it's in the classical pastoral genre, dealing with nymphs and shepherds rather then heroes or real people, so these pastorali were also rappresentationi.


Nevertheless, there's one big 'plus' about the musicologists' having labelled Anima e Corpo as the first oratorio: it was that which led to the work's being published in modern times in a facsimile edition, which led to our discovering it in the musicology library at Detmold and discovering what a unique treasure it was, as Ute as I sang little bits of it in two parts, trying not to disturb the serious theoretical studies of the others in the room which a practical application no-one seemed to have thought of then.

Anima e Corpo then and now
Staging a renaissance opera:
Alessandro Guidotti, 1600
Welcome to the world of
Musica affetuosa!
The 1996 Tartu production
Who did what
Interlocutori
Li stromenti
Why 'opera', not 'oratorio'?

Anima e Corpo main page

Camerata start page