Delightful, empowering:

iDVD3

Great promises not fulfilled, and five days wasted:

iDVD 4

Fine for what it does:

Toast 6

The smooth solution - and via eBay it's even affordable!:

DVD Studio Pro 2

Summary: Capturing video and making a DVD in Mac OS Panther

One user's solutions

iDVD and DVD Studio Pro compared
 
iDVD
DVD Studio Pro
 

basic concept

- for non-experts who want to get started creating DVD discs right away

- to create DVDs containing video and still images with simple menu navigation

- drag-and-drop ease of use

- predesigned themes

- professional DVD authoring tool

- to create DVD discs that include every feature outlined in the DVD-Video specification, with video, still images, audio, and even web links

- for projects that require motion menus, chapter markers, scripting, multiple languages, subtitles, Dolby Digital audio, and other advanced features.

 

output

- burns only with Apple SuperDrive onPower Mac G4 and flat panel iMacs

- burns with Apple SuperDrive + selected third-party DVD-R drives

- save files on digital tape or portable hard drive for a DVD service bureau

 

text: adapted from Apple